Page 1 of 2

Engine mount ala Porsche

Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2016 10:43 pm
by edgedj
In an attempt to reduce NVH in my dav I'm fabbing up a rear crossmember structure to replace the single dangling pivot. I googled a few porsche pics and noticed they have a very different approach to engine suspension to that on imps and davrians. It's bascically a wide bracket solidly mounted to the engine which meets engine mounts inline with the inside face of the rear wheels.

Stage 1 complete - purchase of 2 x porsche Carreras 2 engine mounts
Stage 2 in planning - making a buck for the rear crossmember.

Re: Engine mount ala Porsche

Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2016 10:49 pm
by edgedj
IMG_0021.JPG
IMG_0021.JPG (65.58 KiB) Viewed 8002 times
IMG_0020.JPG

Re: Engine mount ala Porsche

Posted: Mon Dec 12, 2016 8:51 pm
by edgedj
I've been posting pictures on Facebook but in case people here aren't on FB...
20161205_233404357_iOS.jpg
20161205_233344837_iOS.jpg
20161211_182109241_iOS.jpg
20161211_182053057_iOS.jpg

Re: Engine mount ala Porsche

Posted: Tue Dec 13, 2016 2:40 pm
by Teddie2003
So the frame that goes round the engine in Pic 1 is that a f/glass box construction?

Re: Engine mount ala Porsche

Posted: Tue Dec 13, 2016 10:04 pm
by edgedj
yes it's a GRP construction with lots of corematt and weighs in at around 6KG. The arms extend inside the cabin and are glassed in and around the rear spring turrets. If I put enough weight on them I can lift the nose of the car in the air off the axle stands which are about 6" ahead of the rear wheels.

Re: Engine mount ala Porsche

Posted: Thu Dec 15, 2016 2:08 pm
by Teddie2003
So is that something that you made to fit around the engine?

Or have you modified the original frame support so that you could then fit the Porsche type mount?

Re: Engine mount ala Porsche

Posted: Thu Dec 29, 2016 11:56 pm
by edgedj
and now complete! I've only driven it a mile or so but it's really nice to drive, the most startling difference I've noticed so far is the low speed control and setting off, none of the standard imp bite and bounce (which I never noticed until it wasn't there). When you lift the clutch it really steadily applies the power and smoothly heads off. Need to get my windscreen back in next before a bigger test. Seems nice and solid and the engine is way more accessible than ever before with the A frame.
20161229_152612365_iOS.jpg
20161229_152621704_iOS.jpg
20161229_155626966_iOS.jpg
20161229_155631757_iOS.jpg
20161229_155644931_iOS.jpg
This is a completely custom from the ground up build of an engine frame using Porsche mounts, but the frame (GRP) and the engine hanger (steel) are custom made to achieve this.

Now I've re-fitted my windscreen, heading out onto the road tomorrow for a better test.

Dave

Re: Engine mount ala Porsche

Posted: Fri Dec 30, 2016 6:59 pm
by edgedj
update on NVH - after about 20 miles it looks like the harmonic vibrations are gone. I don't know if the A frame or engine mount location was responsible but aside from volume and pitch changes, the painful bass vibrations are gone.

Re: Engine mount ala Porsche

Posted: Fri Feb 10, 2017 8:18 pm
by edgedj
Before the work on the engine frame I used a decibel meter app on my iPhone to record noise in the cabin and with the windows shut I was getting high 60s (67-68) at low running speed and 70-75 when revving over 3krpm

I drove to work yesterday with a decibel meter app running on my iPhone and here are the results, post new engine mount:

Idle : 48-50 dB
normal running: 55-60 dB
high rpm: 60-63 dB
engine running at speed with heater fan: 63-65 dB

In short an amazing difference, the Porsche mounts and their location make a huge difference to transferred noise to the cabin. Idle noise is less than half what it was and running is something like an 80% drop. I can now hear the fuel pump (mounted under the floor) as a whine when driving it's getting that quiet.

Handling is also massively impacted, it corners much more predictably then before and low speed driving is vastly improved with clutch bite point being firm and easy to handle. I always noticed before how an imp novice would struggle to handle set off and more often than not stall the engine, with the wide engine mounts and lack of slop the car sets off really predictably and smoothly. Very hard to define or describe the difference but if you drive a modern car in traffic you'll notice you can just move the clutch up or down smoothly with zero throttle and the car behaves nicely, well an imp engine with wide engine mounts will also do that...

Re: Engine mount ala Porsche

Posted: Sun Jun 18, 2017 7:13 pm
by Hal Mercier
Very impressive I must say!

However, if as you say you had to buy two Carreras just for some bits, can I have the leftovers please? :mrgreen:

Sorry nopt to have been keeping up on the build, but what have you done to the engine, is it now fuel injected? Which system?

Looks like you've been mighty busy on it!